McCutchen Mailday #12: DAMAGED IN TRANSIT 1/1

I have been very fortunate in my online purchases.  I had only received one card (a Freddy Sanchez jersey card) that was poorly damaged in transit and it ran me only $2.  That all changed the other day when I received a 1/1 Red Paper Parallel of Andrew McCutchen from 2012 Bowman.

The package had been missing for over a month.

And this is why...

I was frightened to see what the card looked like on the inside.

Once I took it out, I was pleasantly surprised that the toploader had taken a brunt of the damage.

However, there is a major crease on the right of the card.

I am currently in contact with the seller to try and recover some of the cost for the card as I would like to keep it since it's a 1/1.  However in it's current condition I don't want to pay the $60 tag it came with.